If you suspect identity theft, move quickly. Freeze your credit, report the theft to the Federal Trade Commission, contact the companies where fraud occurred, and dispute fraudulent accounts in writing. Acting early limits the damage, and the records you create now can protect you if a creditor, collector, or credit bureau pushes back later.
This checklist is organized by timing so you know what to do first. Save it, and work through it step by step.
How do you know your identity may have been stolen?
Common warning signs include:
- Charges or withdrawals you don’t recognize
- Bills or collection calls for accounts you never opened
- Credit report entries you don’t recognize
- Denied credit, loans, or jobs for no clear reason
- A rejected tax return because one was already filed in your name
- Medical bills or insurance statements for care you didn’t receive
- Notices about a government benefit claim you didn’t make
- Mail that suddenly stops arriving, or password reset emails you didn’t request
One sign doesn’t prove identity theft, but each one is worth checking right away.
First 24 hours: stop the damage
- Start a log. Write down what you’ve noticed, when you noticed it, and who you’ve contacted. Keep a running record of dates, names, phone numbers, and reference numbers.
- Contact the fraud department of each affected company. Call the bank, card issuer, or lender and ask them to close or freeze the compromised accounts. Follow up in writing and request written confirmation.
- Freeze your credit at all three bureaus. Contact Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion separately. A credit freeze blocks most new accounts from being opened in your name, and federal law makes freezes free. You can lift a freeze temporarily when you need to apply for credit.
- Consider a fraud alert. An initial fraud alert is free and lasts one year, and it tells lenders to take extra steps to verify your identity. With an identity theft report, you may qualify for a longer extended alert. A freeze and a fraud alert can be used together.
- Change passwords and turn on two-factor authentication. Start with your email, bank, and phone carrier accounts, since those can be used to reset everything else. Use unique passwords for each account.
Within the first few days: document everything
- Report the theft to the FTC. Go to IdentityTheft.gov, where you can file a report and get a personalized recovery plan. The report is a useful record, and it can support your disputes.
- Pull your credit reports. AnnualCreditReport.com is the official source for free reports from all three bureaus. Review every account, address, and inquiry, and note anything you don’t recognize.
- Consider filing a police report. Not every case requires one, but some creditors and companies ask for it. If you file, request a copy and the report number.
- Check your mail and your phone. Ask your carrier to add a PIN or lock to your account to guard against a SIM swap, and watch for changes of address that redirect your mail.
Within the first couple of weeks: clean up the damage
- Dispute fraudulent accounts with the credit bureaus. Send a written dispute explaining which items are fraudulent and attach your FTC report and identity documents. Federal law also gives identity theft victims the right to request that fraudulent information be blocked from their report.
- Dispute with the companies that reported the debt. Write to each creditor or lender, explain that the account was opened without your permission, and include your supporting documents.
- Know your rights on unauthorized charges. Under federal law, your liability for unauthorized credit card charges is generally limited, and rules for debit card and bank transfers depend on how quickly you report the problem. Don’t wait.
- Keep proof of everything. Send letters by a trackable method, such as certified mail, and keep copies.
Special situations to watch for
- Tax identity theft. If the IRS rejects your return because one was already filed, you may need to file an identity theft affidavit and consider an IRS Identity Protection PIN. Check whether the Michigan Department of Treasury also needs to be notified.
- Medical identity theft. Request your records from the provider, review them for care you didn’t receive, and notify your health insurer.
- Government benefits fraud. If someone filed a claim in your name, such as for unemployment benefits, report it to the agency right away.
- Stolen license or ID. Contact the Michigan Secretary of State about replacing the document and flagging your record.
When should you talk to a lawyer?
Consider reaching out if:
- You’ve been sued over an account you didn’t open
- A collector keeps contacting you after you disputed the debt
- A credit bureau or creditor refuses to remove fraudulent information
- Your name was used in a criminal case or traffic stop
- The fraud is large, ongoing, or involves your employer, taxes, or benefits
A lawyer can help you send effective disputes, protect your deadlines, push back on collectors, and in some situations pursue claims under consumer protection laws.
Frequently asked questions
Should I freeze my credit or place a fraud alert? Many people do both. A freeze blocks most new accounts, while a fraud alert tells lenders to verify your identity before approving credit.
Does a credit freeze cost money? No. Federal law makes credit freezes free at all three bureaus.
Do I need to file a police report? Not always. An FTC report is often the main record, but some companies ask for a police report, so it can be worth having.
Am I responsible for debts someone opened in my name? Generally not, if you can show the accounts were fraudulent, but you usually must dispute them promptly and keep records.
How long does it take to recover from identity theft? It varies. Some cases resolve in weeks, while others take months, especially when several accounts or agencies are involved.
Can I take legal action against a creditor or credit bureau? In some situations, yes. Federal and state consumer protection laws may apply. A lawyer can review the facts.
Dealing with identity theft in Lansing, East Lansing, or mid-Michigan? Learn more about identity theft help, then call Attorney Tara Nichol at 517-299-5659 for a free consultation.