From The Law Desk of Attorney Tara Nichol

How Long Can a Debt Collector Sue You in Michigan?

In Michigan, a creditor generally has six years to sue you on most consumer debts — credit cards, medical bills, auto loans, and personal loans — under MCL 600.5807. Once that window closes, they lose the legal right to obtain a judgment against you.

But three things about that rule cause more damage than the rule itself protects against:

The clock can reset — sometimes with a single $5 payment. The debt does not disappear when the period expires. And the statute of limitations is an affirmative defense, which means a court will not apply it for you. If a collector sues on a ten-year-old debt and you say nothing, they win.

Here is how to actually use this protection rather than lose it.

The six-year clock, and when it starts

Michigan’s limitations period for most consumer debts is six years. A narrower category — sales contracts for the purchase of goods — carries a four-year period.

The clock does not start when you opened the account. It generally begins running from the date of last activity on the account or the date you defaulted, whichever is later.

So if you stopped making credit card payments in 2020, the creditor generally has until 2026 to file suit.

Determining your actual date of last activity is the single most important fact in these cases, and it is often not obvious from the collection letter. Collectors sometimes report or reference a date that reflects when they acquired the debt, not when you last paid. Your own records and your credit report are better sources.

What “zombie debt” is and why you’re hearing from someone new

Debt buyers purchase portfolios of old, charged-off accounts for pennies on the dollar and attempt to collect on them — often long after the limitations period has run. The industry term is zombie debt.

The business model works because most consumers don’t know the rules. A collector calling about a credit card you forgot about eight years ago may have no legal ability to sue you at all.

Watch for the pattern: they may not mention the limitations period. They may offer a surprisingly low settlement, or a small monthly payment plan, hoping you’ll agree before realizing they cannot actually take you to court. That low offer is not generosity. It is often an attempt to get you to make a payment.

The reset: how a small payment can cost you six years

This is the most consequential thing in this article.

A partial payment or a written acknowledgment of the debt can restart the six-year clock from zero.

Even a small good-faith payment — $5, $20 — can give a collector a fresh six years to file a lawsuit on a debt that was previously unenforceable. So can a written promise to pay, and in some circumstances, a written acknowledgment that the debt is yours.

The practical rule: do not pay anything, promise anything in writing, or acknowledge the debt in writing until you know when the clock started. Not “just to show good faith.” Not “just to get them to stop calling.” That instinct is exactly what the business model is built around.

If you want to stop the calls without risk, send a written cease-communication letter. That does not revive the debt.

What collectors can and cannot do on an expired debt

They can still contact you. The debt does not vanish when the limitations period expires. Collectors may continue to call and send letters seeking voluntary payment.

They cannot sue. Regulation F prohibits filing suit on a time-barred debt.

They cannot threaten to sue. Threatening litigation on a debt they cannot legally bring violates both Regulation F and the FDCPA’s prohibition on threatening action a collector cannot take.

They generally must tell you the debt is old. Regulation F requires collectors to disclose when a debt is too old to sue over.

If a collector threatened you with a lawsuit on an expired debt, or actually filed one, that is a violation carrying statutory damages up to $1,000 plus actual damages and your attorney’s fees — and in a class action, the cap rises to the lesser of $500,000 or 1% of the collector’s net worth.

The affirmative defense trap

This is where people lose cases they should win.

The court will not raise the statute of limitations for you. A judge will not look at a complaint, notice the debt is a decade old, and dismiss it. The system does not work that way.

If a debt buyer sues on a time-barred debt and you do not respond, they will win a default judgment anyway. And once they have that judgment, they can garnish your wages and freeze your bank accounts — completely bypassing the expired limitations period.

The expired statute was a complete defense. Silence converted it into a judgment.

So: you must file an Answer, and you must raise the statute of limitations in it. You have 21 days if personally served, 28 days if served by mail.

After a judgment, a different clock starts

If a judgment is entered, Michigan’s limitations period for an action founded on a judgment is 10 years under MCL 600.5809(3) — and creditors can petition the court to renew it.

That means a judgment can remain collectible for well over a decade. A collector who obtains a default judgment on a time-barred debt gains roughly ten more years of collection power, and can seek renewal beyond that. The judgment can also be sold to another collector.

This is why a default judgment on an old debt is so much worse than the underlying debt ever was.

What to do when an old debt surfaces

Request validation in writing. If you suspect a debt is past the limitations period, request validation under the FDCPA before discussing anything else. You have 30 days from the validation notice to dispute in writing, and a written dispute obligates the collector to cease collection until it provides verification. Send it certified mail.

Determine your date of last activity. Check your own records and pull your credit reports from all three bureaus.

Do not make a payment. Not until you’ve established the timeline.

Do not acknowledge the debt in writing. Be careful about email and text replies.

Document everything. Call logs, voicemails, letters, texts. If they threatened suit on an expired debt, that documentation is your claim.

If you’re sued, respond. This is non-negotiable.

Credit reporting is a separate timeline

One common source of confusion: the statute of limitations and credit reporting are different clocks.

Most negative information — including charged-off accounts and collections — can remain on your credit report for seven years from the date of first delinquency, under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act. That period is not the same as Michigan’s six-year suit deadline, and neither one controls the other.

A debt can be unsuable but still on your report. It can also drop off your report while still being within the suit window. If a collector has re-aged a debt to keep it on your report longer than permitted, that is its own FCRA violation worth examining.

If a collector is pursuing an old debt

The six-year rule is a genuine, powerful protection. It is also the protection consumers most frequently forfeit — by making a small payment, or by not responding to a lawsuit.

If you are being contacted or sued about an old debt in Ingham, Eaton, Genesee, Jackson, or anywhere in Mid-Michigan, I offer a confidential consultation to determine when your clock actually started, whether the debt is enforceable, and whether the collector’s conduct gives you a claim.

Call: 517-299-5659
Book a consultation: www.attorneytaranichol.com/schedule

Tara Nichol is a licensed Michigan trial attorney whose practice focuses on criminal defense and consumer protection. She has been admitted to the State Bar of Michigan since 2011. Headquartered in East Lansing, Michigan, Ms. Nichol accepts cases from Ingham, Eaton, Genesee, and Jackson counties, and throughout Mid-Michigan and beyond. This article is general information about Michigan law, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes and eligibility rules change; verify current law or consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Recent Posts
Categories
Archive
Archives